Carrie Underwood Brought to Tears on American Idol During Emotional Audition
An Emotional Return
Now 41, Carrie joined fellow judges Luke Bryan and Lionel Richie as the panel traveled to Nashville for a round of auditions. In a preview clip, Carrie was overcome with emotion and declared, I’m not okay,
as Luke Bryan comforted her. The moment unfolded when an unexpected story set the stage for a performance that would leave the judges visibly moved.
The Story Behind the Song
Mrs. Davis, a high school English teacher, entered the audition room to introduce her student, Slater Nalley. She revealed that Slater had written a song for her late son Carter, who tragically passed away several years earlier. With quiet humility, Slater explained that though he never knew Carter personally, he felt inspired by his story and wanted to honor his memory through music.
The young singer described the process of writing his song, Traces of You, as a calling: I didn’t know Carter, but after hearing about him, I felt a presence in my life. I knew I needed to do something,
he shared. His teacher praised the song for capturing Carter’s spirit, describing it as filled with light and hope.
“Traces of You” Brings the Judges to Tears
With just his guitar and a voice full of emotion, Slater performed Traces of You. Lyrics such as Your life was like a river running home
and Somewhere past the sky I can feel you dancing in the air
painted a vivid picture of Carter’s life and memory. The performance struck a deep chord with the judges, particularly Carrie Underwood, who could not hold back her tears.
At the end of the performance, Carrie confessed, I couldn’t have imagined you doing that any better.
Lionel Richie echoed the sentiment, praising the young songwriter for his blues-infused lyricism, particularly noting the line, like a river running home.
Other Notable Moments This Season
The upcoming season of American Idol will also see a familiar face from another talent show. Thunderstorm Artis, who placed second on The Voice five years ago, revealed on Instagram that he will audition for Idol. Sharing a photo with his wife and baby in front of the iconic “Idol” sign, Thunderstorm invited fans to tune in on March 9 to see if he made it through to the next round.
Carrie Underwood’s Spotlight Beyond Idol
Carrie’s return to American Idol comes amid ongoing discussion about her past public performances, including her appearance at President Donald Trump’s inauguration. Reports suggested that Carrie was frustrated with how the event was handled, especially after it was unexpectedly moved indoors, limiting attendance. While some controversy surrounded the moment, sources close to her emphasized that she handled the situation with grace despite the challenges.
Producers have since been cautious about keeping American Idol politically neutral, striving to maintain its reputation as a family-friendly show. Regardless of outside attention, Carrie’s professionalism and heartfelt reactions on the judges’ panel continue to remind fans of the authenticity that made her a beloved star.
A Season Full of Heart
As the new season of American Idol premieres on March 9, moments like Slater Nalley’s performance highlight what makes the show special: ordinary people stepping into the spotlight with extraordinary stories. Carrie Underwood’s emotional reaction proved that even seasoned superstars can still be moved by the power of music and its ability to heal, inspire, and connect.