When the Cowboy Became a Cradle Long after the spotlight dims, this is the Toby Keith that endures — not the performer, but the grandfather. Wearing his Oklahoma hoodie and cap, eyes closed, holding a sleeping baby to his chest, Toby isn’t chasing applause here. He’s found something deeper: peace. Not the kind earned on stage, but the kind born of love, stillness, and legacy. For all the songs about grit and glory, this quiet moment says just as much. No stage. No words. Just a cowboy, and a cradle.

Introduction “My List” is a reflective country ballad recorded by Toby Keith and written by Tim James and Rand Bishop. Released as the third single from Keith’s 2001 album Pull…