ON THIS DAY IN 1968: Conway Twitty Earned His First Country #1 Hit With “Next In Line” — And The Unbelievable Story Behind His Name Still Amazes Fans

Introduction

It was October 1968 when a young man from Friars Point, Mississippi, officially cemented his place in country music history. Conway Twitty, whose smooth baritone would one day define an era, earned his first #1 country hit with “Next In Line” — a dark, aching ballad about heartbreak and hope that announced his arrival as more than just a former rock ’n’ roller.

But before he became a household name — before the suits, the fame, and the timeless love songs — he was just Harold Lloyd Jenkins, a kid with big dreams, a bigger voice, and no idea what to call himself.

The story of how he became Conway Twitty has been told in countless interviews, but hearing it from him was always something special. As he once recalled with a smile:

“I knew Harold Lloyd Jenkins wasn’t gonna fit on a marquee. I needed something people would remember — something that sounded right coming out of a radio.”

One night, flipping through an atlas, he found two towns that caught his eye — Conway, Arkansas, and Twitty, Texas. He said he laughed out loud when he said them together: “Conway Twitty — now that’s a name with rhythm!”

And just like that, the legend was born.

By the time “Next In Line” hit the charts, Twitty had already walked away from a successful rock ’n’ roll career. His early hits like “It’s Only Make Believe” had made him a teen idol, but he never felt at home in that world. Country music, with its honesty and soul, was where his heart belonged.

The transition wasn’t easy — critics doubted him, radio stations hesitated — but “Next In Line” proved everyone wrong. The song’s haunting melody and heartfelt delivery showcased a side of Twitty few had heard before: vulnerable, authentic, and unmistakably country. It was the beginning of a second act that would produce 55 #1 hits, countless awards, and one of the most enduring legacies in American music.

Reflecting on those early days, Conway once said,

“I never set out to be famous. I just wanted to sing songs that felt true. And somehow, that’s what worked.”

Decades later, “Next In Line” still stands as a turning point — the song that transformed Harold Jenkins into Conway Twitty, and the moment when country music gained one of its most soulful storytellers.

So the next time you hear that familiar voice glide through a verse — smooth as velvet, heavy with truth — remember that somewhere between Conway, Arkansas, and Twitty, Texas, a name was born that the world would never forget.

Video

You Missed

THE WORLD WHISPERED ABOUT A SCANDALOUS AFFAIR BEHIND THEIR 14 HITS — BUT WHEN A SUDDEN ANEURYSM TOOK CONWAY IN 1993, LORETTA LOST HER SAFEST PLACE…. Throughout the 1970s, Conway Twitty and Loretta Lynn set the country music charts on fire…. With four straight CMA Vocal Duo of the Year awards and unforgettable classics like “Louisiana Woman, Mississippi Man,” their chemistry felt dangerously real….. The public heard the guilty ache in “After the Fire Is Gone” and immediately assumed the worst. They whispered about hotel rooms, secret romances, and forbidden love….. But behind the velvet curtain, there was no scandal…… Conway wasn’t her lover. He was her fiercely loyal protector in a notoriously ruthless industry….. He was the only man who could perfectly match her raw Appalachian twang with a smooth, intimate growl. Every duet sounded like a private conversation accidentally broadcast on the radio….. Then came 1993. The sudden aneurysm didn’t just end a legendary partnership. It broke Loretta’s heart more than any romantic breakup ever could….. For nearly thirty years after his death, under countless stage lights, Loretta kept stepping to the microphone, a solo queen carrying the weight of a legendary era….. But every time she sang those iconic hits, she had to look over at the empty, shadowed space where her best friend used to stand…. They never needed a real affair….. They left behind a musical romance so powerful that the silence he left on that stage is still deafening.

THEY SAID CONWAY TWITTY WHISPERED THE OPENING OF “IT’S ONLY MAKE BELIEVE” BECAUSE HE DIDN’T WANT TO WAKE THE OTHER HOTEL GUESTS. BUT THE TRUTH WAS HE WAS JUST HOLDING HIS BREATH BEFORE LETTING HIS HEART COMPLETELY SHATTER IN FRONT OF THE WORLD….. In the summer of 1958, inside a sweltering hotel room in Ontario, a young man named Harold Lloyd Jenkins was quietly strumming his guitar….. He wasn’t the country music giant we’d later know. He was just a lonely guy trying to make sense of a melody in the dark….. He began murmuring the lyrics to “It’s Only Make Believe,” keeping his voice so low it sounded like a secret. It was supposed to be a gentle plea about unrequited love. A quiet illusion….. But when he finally stepped into the studio, something shifted. He didn’t just sing the words. He let them bleed….. He started in that same low, trembling murmur. Then, verse by verse, the pain began to build….. By the time he reached the final crescendo, he was no longer singing. He was begging….. That famous, roaring climax wasn’t a studio trick. It wasn’t just a vocal run. It was the undeniable sound of a man watching a beautiful illusion shatter, captured entirely in one raw take….. He would go on to score fifty number-one country hits. He would become a legend under the arena lights….. But long before the grand stages, there was just a lonely voice in a hot room, reminding us that sometimes, the most painful reality is realizing it was only make believe.

TRE TWITTY AND TAYLA LYNN ARE BRINGING THEIR FAMILIES BACK TO A SHARED STAGE — BUT THE REAL EMOTION IS WATCHING A BLOODLINE REFUSE TO LET A LEGENDARY PROMISE FADE AWAY…… Tre Twitty and Tayla Lynn are currently traveling across the country, stepping up to microphones that once belonged to the most iconic duo in country music history. They are singing the timeless songs that made their grandparents, Conway Twitty and Loretta Lynn, absolute legends…… For decades, Conway and Loretta shared more than just a stage and a string of number-one hits. They shared a profound, unshakable friendship and a professional loyalty that defined an entire era. When they passed away, the world naturally assumed the heavy velvet curtain had finally closed on that historic partnership….. But country music has always been a place where memories refuse to stay quiet…… When Tre and Tayla stand under those familiar lights today, they aren’t just putting on a nostalgic cover show. It is the sound of bloodlines harmonizing. They are proving that two families still stand by each other, still respect each other, and still belong together exactly where it all started….. Conway and Loretta may be gone, but the magic they built didn’t end with their final bow. It is a beautiful reminder that the greatest songs don’t disappear when the original voices leave us — they simply wait for the next generation to pick up the microphone and keep the promise alive.